အလည္လာတာ ေက်းဇူးပါ။ မိတ္ေဆြအားလံုး ေပ်ာ္ရႊင္ေသာ မဂၤလာ႐ွိေသာ ေန႔ရက္မ်ားကို ရယူပိုင္ဆိုင္ႏိုင္ပါေစ။

Sunday, June 21, 2009

THE U.S GOVERNMENT CONTROL IN EDUCATION

A system education finance in which parent can get tuition certificated that can used to attend private or public schools that is represent the education voucher. The potential advantage and disadvantage listed are below. For that program lower income family can get a chance for the good education also promote their social community. On the other hand, there are the increased inequality, loss public sphere and authoritative cost will high are turn out the side effect of the school voucher system. The good things are that increased choices, greater competition and parental judgment are improved for education system.

School voucher system is introduced by economist Milton Friedman in 1955. This allows families to select the public or private schools of their choice and have all or part of the tuition paid. Scholarships are advocated on the grounds that parental choice and competition between public and private schools will improve education for all children. Vouchers can be funded and administered by the government, by private organizations, or by some combination of both. So that, free markets for educational services have consistently done a better job of serving the public than government-run school systems.

The competition through free market capitalism would increase the quality of education for both private and public education sectors as it has for higher education with publicly funded state universities directly competing against private universities. Also, similar competition has helped in manufacturing, energy, transportation, and parcel postal sectors of government that have been socialized and later opened up to free market competition.

The certain studies have suggested there is no marketable difference between the year before school voucher programs started and the following year. They state only slight increases in student performance after school voucher programs are implemented. If the program is supposed to improve educational standards, then where is the evidence? Funds and support for our hard-working public school teachers is what we need. Not the paper promises of a failed program. On the other hand, the most of parents are not pleased with public school performance, but they are happy with their own children schools. They believe that the public schools do not satisfactorily meet the needs of today's children.

Although there is the increased inequality, loss public sphere and authoritative cost will high are turn out the side effect of the school voucher system, the most of the parents want to send their children to the private school. Because the performance of the public school still need to be improved the needs and wants of the parents’ desire. So the school voucher system under the government control is still need to give the competition of the private & public school. That will give the better environment of the education.

References:

Friedman, Milton ; “The Role Of Government in Education”

Friedman, Milton; Wall Street Journal. (Eastern edition). New York, N.Y.: Jun 9, 2005. pg. A.16

A Choice for Public Education Reform; http://www.uh.edu/~lnielsen/pdf_files/mkted2.pdf

School voucher; http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/School_voucher

School vouchers/Scholarships: a condensed summary of the debate; http://www.americanchronicle.com/articles/view/55958

11 comments:

Apprenticeship said...

အရင္းရွင္စီးပြားေရးစနစ္မွာ ကြားဟမႈေတြေတာ့ အၿမဲရွိေနအံုးမွာပဲ.. ႏိုင္ငံတႏိုင္ငံမွာ အားလံုးပညာတတ္ႀကီးပဲ ဆိုရင္ revolution ျဖစ္တတ္တယ္တဲ့။ အဲဒီ revolution မျဖစ္ေအာင္ အစိုးရရဲ႕ အဓိကႀကိဳးကိုင္းနည္းက ပညာေရးေပါ့။ ပညာေရး စနစ္က ႏိုင္ငံအတြက္ လိုအပ္တဲ့ အလုပ္သမား အမ်ိဳးမ်ိဳးကို ေမြးထုတ္ေပးရတယ္ေလ.. သမတၱ မသည္ အိမ္သာေဆးတဲ့လူေတြ အထိေပါ့...။ စနစ္တစ္ခုရဲ႕ သားေကာင္ေတြေပါ့ဗ်ာ..... :(
ဒီမွာေတာ့ school ရဲ႕ quality ေတြ ေျပာၾကတယ္.. ငါတို႕တိုင္းျပည္က ေက်ာင္းေတြက school ရဲ႕ characteristic ေတြေတာင္ မေျပာႏိုင္ေသးဘူး။ :(

Anyway a good article. Did you write it?

Heartmuseum said...

Ap ေရ..... ေက်းဇူးေနာ္...... ၿမန္မာၿပည္ကို သတိရလို႔ ကြ်န္ေတာ္ တင္လိုက္တာ..... ေက်ာင္းမွာတင္ဖို႔ ေရးထားတဲ့ Paper ေလ။ ကိုယ္တိုင္ေရးေပါ့.....

My Wonderful Moral Thoughts said...

In my personal opinion., Education is very important for everyone and it will make you better to have a level of living in life.

To choose the quality of school also can be important as you can achieve prestige through from the reputation.

Former president Bill Clinton said, ''Get education as much as you can when you are young and it will makes life better when you get older. No one can rob or take it away from you is your education and achievement.''

I like his speech very much about education and still remember it when i were having difficult time to do while i study at school. That's give me strength somehow and i can easily to passed my hard time.

Good luck with your paper. It was nice to read.

All the best.

Nandar :))

Heartmuseum said...

နႏၵာေရ..... နင့္ရဲ႕ အေတြးအၿမင္ကို သေဘာတူပါ၏။
ၿမန္မာစကားပံု ႐ွိတယ္ေလဟာ.... "ပညာေရႊအိုး၊ လူမခိုး" တဲ့..... သိတယ္ဟုတ္.... နင္အဲဒီလို ေၿပာေတာ့ ငါေလ... ငါတို႔ ငယ္ငယ္က အေဖ အၿမဲေၿပာေနက် စကားေလး ၿမင္ေယာင္ရင္း မဆီမဆိုင္ အေဖ့ကို သတိရမိတယ္။ အေဖက သူပညာ မတတ္ေပမယ့္ သူ႔သားသမီး ၉ေယာက္လံုး ပညာတတ္ၿဖစ္ရမယ္။ သားသမီးေတြရဲ႕ ပညာေရး အတြက္ဆို ဘယ္ေလာက္ပဲ ကုန္ကုန္ တခ်က္ကေလးမွ မညည္းၿငဴခဲ့ဖူး။ သားသမီးေတြ ပညာတတ္ ၿဖစ္ဖို႔ရာအတြက္ သူမ်ားဆီမွာ ကြ်န္ခံ ရမယ္ဆိုေတာင္ သူကြ်န္ခံၿပီး ပညာသင္ခိုင္းမယ္လို႔ တဖြဖြ ေၿပာခဲ့ဖူးတယ္။ တိုက္တိုက္ဆိုင္ဆိုင္ ဒီေန႔ အေဖမ်ားေန႔ေနာ္..... ဟုတ္တယ္... မဟုတ္လား.....။

My Wonderful Moral Thoughts said...

အေဖမ်ားေန႔မွာ အေဖကုိ သတိရတာ ေကာင္းတာေပါ႔။

ဦးဟတ္ အေဖက သူပညာ မတတ္ေပမယ့္ သူ႔သားသမီး ၉ေယာက္လံုး ပညာတတ္ၿဖစ္ရမယ္ ဆုိတဲ႔ရည္႐ြယ္ခ်က္နဲ႔ သားသမီးေတြရဲ႕ ပညာေရး အတြက္ဆို ဘယ္ေလာက္ပဲ ကုန္ကုန္ တခ်က္ကေလးမွ မညည္းၿငဴပဲ ပညာသင္ေပး ႏုိင္ခဲ႔ျခင္းဟာလဲ သူ႔အရည္အျခင္း တရပ္လုိ႔ ဆုိရမႇာေပါ႔။

အေဖမ်ားေန႔မွာ ဦးဟတ္အတြက္ အေဖဆုိတာ မရွိေတာ႔ေပမယ္႔ သူ႔ Spirit သူ႔ Soul ဟာ ဦးဟတ္နား ရွိေနမယ္ဆုိတာ နႏၵာ ယုံၾကည္တယ္။

မိဘက ပညာအေမြ ေပးႏုိင္ရင္ ကုိယ္က ဒီပညာနဲ႔ ဘဝမွာ ေအာင္ျမင္ေအာင္ ရပ္တည္ ေနႏုိင္ျခင္းဟာ မိဘကုိ ေက်းဇူးဆပ္ျခင္း တမ်ိဳးလုိ႔ နႏၵာကေတာ႔ လက္ခံ ထားတယ္။

ဦးဟတ္ ေအာင္ျမင္ပါေစ။

ခင္တဲ႔
နႏၵာ

ငွက္ကေလး said...

ဦးဟတ္ၾကီး မ်ားက အဂၤလိပ္စာ ျမင္ရင္ ေခါင္းကုိက္ပါတယ္ ဆုိမွ တကယ္ေျပာမယ္ ဖတ္မသြားဘူး သိလား ျမန္မာလုိျပန္ေပးမလားးးး ဒါဆိုရင္ဖတ္မယ္ ဟုတ္ျပီလားးးးး ဘုိင္

တာ႔တာ

ကဗ်ာဦး said...

ငါတို႔ ငယ္ငယ္က အေဖ အၿမဲေၿပာေနက် စကားေလး ၿမင္ေယာင္ရင္း မဆီမဆိုင္ အေဖ့ကို သတိရမိတယ္။ အေဖက သူပညာ မတတ္ေပမယ့္ သူ႔သားသမီး ၉ေယာက္လံုး ပညာတတ္ၿဖစ္ရမယ္။ သားသမီးေတြရဲ႕ ပညာေရး အတြက္ဆို ဘယ္ေလာက္ပဲ ကုန္ကုန္ တခ်က္ကေလးမွ မညည္းၿငဴခဲ့ဖူး။ သားသမီးေတြ ပညာတတ္ ၿဖစ္ဖို႔ရာအတြက္ သူမ်ားဆီမွာ ကြ်န္ခံ ရမယ္ဆိုေတာင္ သူကြ်န္ခံၿပီး ပညာသင္ခိုင္းမယ္လို႔ တဖြဖြ ေၿပာခဲ့ဖူးတယ္။ တိုက္တိုက္ဆိုင္ဆိုင္ ဒီေန႔ အေဖမ်ားေန႔ေနာ္..... ဟုတ္တယ္... မဟုတ္လား.....။

ကဗ်ာကအေဖပဲ ရွိၿပီးဦးဟတ္အေဖေျပာသလို ကဗ်ာ့အေဖကလည္းအဲလိုေျပာခဲ့တယ္
ဒါေၾကာင့္ ကဗ်ာႏိုင္ငံျခားထြက္ၿပီး ပညာကိုရေအာင္သင္ေနတာ
ျမန္မာျပည္ရဲ့ပညာေရးစနစ္ကေတာ့
လံုးဝကိုသံုးမရပါဘူးဦးဟတ္
ဘြဲ႔ရေတြက ၁၀၉-၁၁၀ မ်ားတယ္
ဝမ္းနည္းစရာပဲ

khin oo may said...

သံုးလုိ႕ရလုိ႕သ့ံဳးစားေနပါတယ္။

khin oo may said...

သေဘာတက်ဖတ္သြားပါတယ။္ ေအာင္ၿမင္ပါေစ. ဆထက္တပုိး။

မသက္ဇင္ said...

ကိုဟတ္ေရ
လာဖတ္သြားတယ္ေနာ္
ခင္မင္လ်က္

Heartmuseum said...

နႏၵာေရ... ေပးတဲ့ဆုနဲ႔ ၿပည့္ပါ့ေစလို႔....
ငွက္မေရ..... အၿမင္မေတာ္ရင္...... ဘာသာၿပန္ေပးပါ... :D
လူ႐ွိန္မလားလို႔ ဖိန္႔ႀကည့္တာဟ.... :P
ကဗ်ာဦးေရ... ပညာကေတာ့ တကယ္တန္ဖိုးထားရင္ ကိုယ္တိုင္ေလ့လာ ရတာပဲေလ... အင္းးးးး အလုပ္ မရတာေတာ့ အစိုးရ ေႀကာင့္ေပါ့ေလ.....
အမ ခင္ဦးေမေရ..... ဆုေတာင္းေပးတာ ေက်းဇူးေနာ္...
အမသက္ဇင္..... မအားတဲ့ႀကားက ဝင္လာတာ ေက်းဇူး..